Gwilym Jones
About Author
July 8, 2021

What to do when trusts are untrustworthy

Henderson & Jones has recently taken control over a number of significant property assets for the benefit of bankruptcy estates. In these cases the bankrupt (and certain connected parties) had asserted that the properties were held on trust  which had prevented the trustees from realising them through the normal routes.

H&J conducted detailed investigations into the circumstances surrounding the creation of the purported trusts and identified compelling evidence that the trusts were in fact a sham designed to unlawfully prevent the properties from falling into the bankruptcy estate. In one of these cases, there was (apparently) no original of the trust deed. A copy was made available and purported to be dated many years prior to the bankruptcy. The document, however, had a number of unusual features which were forensically investigated - including conducting detailed handwriting analysis and investigating and making enquiries of the apparent witness to the trust deed.  We made an application to Court for a declaration that the trust was a sham and for possession and sale of the properties. It proved crucial in this case that the defendants were apparently unwilling to risk perjuring themselves by providing a witness statement accompanied by a statement of truth supporting the trust deed. The defendants therefore sought to delay provision of their formal evidence for as long as possible. This weakness ultimately enabled a swift outcome to the case without a hearing being required. The settlement is expected to realise hundreds of thousands of pounds for the benefit of the bankruptcy estate when the properties are sold.

In these cases H&J did not take assignment of officeholder claims from the trustee in bankruptcy (which are not covered by the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015 insolvency reforms). Instead, H&J purchased the trustee's interest in the properties. The applications mentioned above were then jointly sought by H&J and the trustee (importantly H&J met the legal costs of these applications and provided the trustees and the estates with an indemnity to protect against any liabilities arising from them).

This innovative approach to assignments is just one example of the many tools H&J can offer to help office holders to realise value from difficult assets which are protected under purported trusts or other claims.

More Posts

You Might Also Like

Read More

Hospitality sector dines out on Business Interruption COVID-19 victories

Many businesses forced to close during the COVID-19 pandemic held business interruption insurance policies they had envisaged would provide them with coverage. The 2020 Supreme Court test case judgment only considered the wording set out in certain standard policies issued by a handful of insurers leaving many policyholders uncertain as to whether their claims would be covered. A series of High Court decisions this year have helped to address some of that uncertainty - and we explore below a number of decisions which have largely been favourable to policyholders.
Dec 2, 2022
Lauren Pender
Read More

COVID pandemic: the perfect petri dish for cultivating fraud

The COVID-19 pandemic is without precedent in modern times. Its impact has spread across the globe infecting our lives for nearly two years. An unfortunate consequence of the pandemic is also likely to be an explosion of fraud cases. In this article, Piers Elliott and Lauren Pender examine the reasons why.
Feb 24, 2022
Piers Elliott
Read More
News / Press Releases

John Doyle Construction v Erith Contractors

The Court of Appeal today handed down judgment in John Doyle Construction v Erith Contractors regarding the enforcement of adjudication decisions by insolvent companies.  The Court of Appeal seems to disagree with the Supreme Court's decision in Bresco v Lonsdale and its decision will create significant uncertainty for insolvent claimants in the construction industry. Please see below some of our thoughts on the judgment.
Oct 7, 2021
Philip Henderson