Philip Henderson
About Author
October 7, 2021
 in 
News / Press Releases

John Doyle Construction v Erith Contractors

In Bresco Electrical Services Ltd v Michael J Lonsdale (Electrical) Ltd [2019] ECWA Civ 27, the Court of Appeal (with the leading judgment given by Coulson LJ) concluded that there was a “fundamental incompatibility between the adjudication regime and the insolvency set-off regime" (paragraph 42).

The Court of Appeal’s judgment was overturned by the Supreme Court in Bresco Electrical Services Ltd v Michael J Lonsdale (Electrical) Ltd [2020] UKSC 25 with Lord Briggs noting: “I do not regard construction adjudication as in any way incompatible with the operation of the insolvency code in general, or with insolvency set-off in particular.” (paragraph 42)

For many, it is therefore surprising that, despite Lord Briggs’s findings in Bresco, the Court of Appeal (with the leading judgment again given by Coulson LJ) has today concluded in John Doyle Construction v Erith Contractors [2021] EWCA Civ 1542 that there remains a “fundamental incompatibility between the adjudication regime and the insolvency set-off regime” (paragraph 93).

This judgment creates significant uncertainty for insolvent claimants in the construction industry, which is especially unhelpful in the post-pandemic era. This decision may unfortunately encourage non-payment of amounts due to insolvent companies and could embolden contractors to refuse to pay insolvent entities.

John Doyle will now pursue its claim through the Courts. The adjudication decision in its favour may not be directly enforceable but, as noted by Coulson LJ, “the fact that the adjudicator has apparently considered the claims and found in the claimant’s favour will put the defendant on the back foot throughout” the ensuing litigation.

More Posts

You Might Also Like

Read More
News / Press Releases

New Birmingham Office Address

Office relocation
Sep 4, 2023
Liz Foley
Read More
Articles

Litigation: Asset classes in insolvency. Is a bird in the hand worth two in the bush?

In this article, first published in INSOL Europe's Eurofenix's Summer 2023 magazine, Gwilym Jones and Piers Elliott examine the options available to office holders when seeking to make realisations from litigation claims.
Jul 1, 2023
Gwilym Jones
Read More
News / Press Releases

H&J retains Chambers ranking & Philip Henderson recognised as a leading individual

H&J is pleased to have retained its Band 2 ranking in Chambers & Partners 2023 for insolvency litigation funding. We are also delighted that Philip Henderson has been recognised as a leading individual.
Jun 28, 2023
Sophie Samani